All manuals Author Editor Plagiarism Reviewer

Reviewer manual

Second reviewer account: reviewer3@iba-du.edu / username reviewer3 / password Jba12345.

What this user does

The reviewer opens assigned papers, accepts or declines, then submits comments, scores, a recommendation, and an optional annotated file. The author does not see this until the editor approves Reviewer 1 / 2 / 3.

Workshop use case

  1. Either open the 14-day link the editor copied, or log in at Login with reviewer2@iba-du.edu / Jba12345.
  2. You land on Reviewer — my assignments.
  3. Open Editor PDF / Editor DOC (author files are not shown to reviewers).
  4. If this is a second review of the same paper, you skip accept/decline and go straight to Submit review form.
  5. Click I will review this paper (first invitation only) or decline to show that path.
  6. Click Submit review form. Fill comments and criteria (originality, analytical rigour, clarity, research applications, internationality).
  7. Confidential comments go only to the editor — mention that in the workshop.
  8. Choose a recommendation (e.g. Paper maybe accepted, after changes).
  9. Optional: attach an annotated PDF or Word file. Submit.
  10. Finished work appears under Completed.

The author sees your comments only after the editor clicks Approve Reviewer … for author. Log out before switching accounts.

Journal of Business Administration — IBA, University of Dhaka · Training accounts password: Jba12345